Fun with Color

A guide to our favorite healthy mascaras

Lily Lolo mascara

We're a very, very picky bunch; you may know this already. It's one of the reasons why we keep our product collection so tightly edited. Another reason is that we don't want to overwhelm you unnecessarily with choice — but still, it can sometimes be hard to figure out which way to go.

And that's what our Guides are here for: call us anytime or email help@aylabeauty.com and we'll help you find just the right thing. But we know: sometimes you just want a snappy little guide. Here's a quick way to sort through our mascara choices.

For a natural look: Lily Lolo Natural Vegan Mascara
This smudge-proof best seller holds a curl, defines, separates, and darkens lashes with a creamy, fast-drying, flake-free formula. 

For length: Inika Long Lash Vegan Mascara
This weightless formula builds beautifully to lengthen and lift lashes while feeling like you're wearing nothing on them at all. (Available in Brown, too, just for all you gingers who've requested it.)

For volume: Lily Lolo Big Lash Mascara
Also vegan, this formula delivers fuller lashes in an easy-breezy way: it pumps up the volume of lashes significantly but still dries quickly for easy application.

For overall drama: Manasi7 Precision Mascara
The darkest, thickest formula on our shelves, this blackest-black mascara tends to be the makeup pros' favorite for its versatility and color payoff. 

You May Also like

Body & Mind

Perimenopause, Post-Menopause, and Everything In Between: A Gynecologist Sets the Record Straight

Dr. Jila Senemar explains the hormonal stages of perimenopause and menopause, busts common HRT myths, weighs in on GLP-1s, and shares exactly what to ask your doctor.

Spring 2026 makeup must-haves

Our wonderful makeup pro, Kelly, loves to share quick tips and makeup bag edits in her express lessons, which are done both here in our SF studio and via video, wherever you are. We asked her to share her must-haves...

Our 2026 Beauty Shortlist Awards

We are over the moon about this news: The Beauty Shortlist named Ayla the “Green Beauty Retailer of the Year” for the third year in a row! And the Dara Kennedy products are having a moment: Dara Kennedy Sea Serum won...